| Criteria |
Weight |
Bad (1–25) |
Good (26–50) |
Distinction (51–75) |
Excellence (76–100) |
| Literature Study & Knowledge Foundation |
10% |
Fewer than 3 relevant references; not uploaded to KM Portal |
Fewer than 6 relevant references; uploaded to KM Portal |
Fewer than 9 relevant references; well documented in KM Portal |
12 or more high-quality relevant references; strongly integrated and documented in KM Portal |
| Risk & Sustainability Management |
15% |
Risks not defined |
Risks identified but mitigation is weak |
Risks well identified with workable mitigation plan |
Comprehensive risk, governance, and long-term sustainability strategy in place |
| Impact Realization (Output & Outcome) |
30% |
Output unclear; no measurable impact |
Clear output with impact at unit/department level |
Measurable impact at Business Unit/Directorate level |
Significant measurable impact at BINUS Group level with national/international relevance |
| Implementation Maturity |
30% |
Not implemented |
Partially implemented |
Mostly implemented and functioning |
Fully implemented, institutionalized, and scalable across units/ecosystem |
| Novelty & Strategic Value Creation |
15% |
Existing solution with minor improvement |
Moderate improvement from existing solution |
Significant enhancement creating new value |
New to BINUS Group/national level and contributes to intelligent society development |
